Packaging · Diagnosis

Broken Band, Smiley Band and Missing Band: 3 Failures, Same Causes

Visual comparison of broken band, smiley band and missing band on PET caps
From left to right: Broken Band (complete horizontal separation), Smiley Band (partial separation) and Missing Band (total loss before application).

In this article

  1. The three failures and how to tell them apart
  2. Diagnosis trap: check cocked cap first
  3. Possible causes — Cap
  4. Possible causes — Bottle
  5. Possible causes — Capper
  6. Possible causes — Cap feeder
  7. Next step

The three failures and how to tell them apart

The three failures — Broken Band, Smiley Band (partial band rupture) and Missing Band — are addressed together by the packaging technical guide precisely because they share the same root causes. The difference is only the severity of the visible defect:

Image: smiley-band.jpeg
Smiley band — partial rupture of the band forming the characteristic "smile".
Image: missing-band.jpeg
Missing band — cap that arrived at the capper already without the tamper-evidence band.

From the consumer's standpoint, all three compromise the band's primary function: showing whether the package has been opened. For the line engineer, they are the same problem with different levels of manifestation.

Diagnosis trap: check cocked cap first

Before investigating

If the cap thread is damaged, the root problem may be a cocked cap (tilt at the moment of application) and not the band itself. See the cocked cap diagnosis first — correcting the tilt often makes band defects disappear as well.

Possible causes — Cap

Cap condition before application carries huge weight in these defects. Cold caps break, poorly stored caps deform, lots with low pull test give way under any load:

ItemCauseSolution
2.1.1Excessively cold caps.Condition caps between 18 and 35 °C for at least 24 hours before use. This conditioning is still the most common mistake when the truck arrives early in the morning and production starts before noon.
2.1.2Caps damaged in storage or handling.Inspect boxes. Open by cutting or pulling the tape carefully. Cap pallets must not be stacked more than 2 pallets high.
2.1.3Fragile band or low pull test.Engage the supplier's technical support for sample testing. Pull test low from the factory cannot be solved by machine adjustment — it requires a lot change.

Possible causes — Bottle

The bottle finish, if out of dimensions, forces the cap against the band during threading — and the band ruptures:

ItemCauseSolution
2.2.1Dimensional excess on the bottle finish.Check with a "go/no-go" gauge. Contact the packaging supplier.

Possible causes — Capper

This is the longest and most frequent list. Wrong vertical load, sorter speed above the recommended range, transfer star out of sync — all of them break bands in series. Broken bands then often jam downstream flow; see the chute jamming diagnosis for the cascade effect:

ItemCauseSolution
2.3.1Excessive vertical load.Adjust between 20 and 40 lb. Load above that crushes the band against the cap shoulder.
2.3.2Capper turret too high or too low.Check head reference (Magna Torq: reference line matching the upper edge of the housing).
2.3.3Foreign bodies in the chuck.Remove stuck band remnants. Investigate the root cause of the inverted cap that produced the residue.
2.3.4Bottle control guides and star wheels out of position.Review star wheel sync, rear guide and part formats.
2.3.5Sorter speed too high.Up to 8 heads: 22 to 25 rpm. Above 8: 28 to 30 rpm. Higher speed breaks bands by disc friction.
2.3.6Cap level in the sorter too high.Keep between 1/4 and 1/3 of total capacity. Excess caps compress those below against the disc.
2.3.7Sorter disc running continuously.Install auto-stop sensors when the chute is full.
2.3.8Sorter disc running in the reverse direction.Check the correct direction in the manual.
2.3.9Gap between sorter plates too small.Add shims or adjust disc fixation.
2.3.10Caps or glass remnants in the star wheel / anti-rotation bases.Clean anything that may lift or push the bottle away from vertical.
2.3.11 (C.I.H.)Cap transfer star wheel out of adjustment.Adjust the Cap In Head transfer star wheel to align the cap with the head.
2.3.14 (C.I.H.)Cap lock mini-cylinder not retracted.Replace the mini-cylinder with a compatible OEM replacement part. Adjust air pressure between 4 and 6 kg/cm².
2.3.16 (P.O.)Pre-torque serrated arm spring with no or excessive tension.Replace the spring with one of proper tension.
2.3.17 (P.O.)Cap launcher failure.Inspect arm centering and opening (~25.4 mm).
2.3.18 (P.O.)Pre-torque misadjusted.Serrated arm must engage at mid-height of the cap.

Possible causes — Cap feeder

When the defect persists even with the equipment adjusted, the problem may lie before the sorter — in the feeding system. Practical test: feed the sorter manually with a suitable container. If the defect disappears, the problem is in the feeder:

ItemCauseSolution
2.4.1Jet Flow air flow too high.Reduce to the minimum possible without affecting feeding.
2.4.2Protruding edges in feeder tubes.Reinstall tubes eliminating edges where caps hit.
2.4.3Bends with too small radius or obstructed tubes.Replace or clean.
2.4.4Ineffective decelerator.Improve the design so caps actually slow down before falling into the sorter.

Next step

Broken band is only one of the 13 most common capping problems. The complete technical guide also covers cocked cap, high cap, under-applied cap, split closure (cracked cap), CO₂ leak and more. All in a single, free reference.

Guide to Cap Application Problems

The 13 most common capper failures — diagnosis, root cause and correction. Free technical material.

Download the full guide →